Heater core flush or replace

ishai1856

Full Member
Joined
Nov 10, 2011
Messages
126
Reaction score
0
Points
16
Buick Ownership
Buick
my heat only gets hot after I accelerate, if I let it idle for a while it goes cool. I am also getting the telltale film on the windshield when the defroster is on - it isnt bad but its not fun to clean. Should I flush the heater core or just replace it? in the morning I'm going to test the lines but I suspect it'll be clogged. My engine isn't overheating and my coolant level is right where it should be and looks clean and green. Am I going to get the film even if I flush? it's only 47.50 after shipping from rockauto to get the same one i'd get from the local Napa and the repair looks a hell of a lot easier than that blend door actuator.
 
WOOHOO! same one, 41.77 delivered from Amazon.com. If the hose test shows a core issue, i'll be replacing it.
 
Last edited:
I'm with Silverfox on this. The leak may not make the level drop noticeably, but if you have a sweet-smelling slightly viscous film on the windshield when the defroster is running then you have a leak. Flushing won't cure the leak and in fact may make it worse.

Replacement is the best option, although, since you do get heat out of it, you might temporarily get away with a sealant. Is that what you meant when you said "flush"?

The sealants were you just pour in something into the existing coolant and put the cap back on don't usually last very long -- ok for an emergency "get it home" situation at best. The best sealants require the system to be drained, flushed repeatedly with water, sealant added, engine run at fast idle for ~30 minutes, then more flushing with water and finally refilling with coolant.

I have successfully used one of those to fix a cracked block issue (on a 3200) where replacement of the part would have been a lot of time and money, but for a heater core, at that price, why bother?
 
______________________________

Help support this site so it can continue supporting you!
Why ? Because the heater core is a *%$#&^% to replace! I just did mine and it’s a miserable job, at least if you are 6’3” and have a back problem! If you don’t have a back problem before you start, you will by the time you are done! ;-> I got it changed, but I don’t want to do it again, so I certainly didn’t buy the cheapest one around.

I’ve used “sealers” with good results in the past, and was considering this approach about a year and a half ago, as a temporary repair for a leaking radiator, which I did then replace. Sealers have to be poured into the top of the radiator, preferably with the engine hot and running and circulated through the system for some time, for them to work properly. If they aren’t circulated immediately, they will cause “clogs” in the cooling system. They can clog radiators so badly that the only “fix” is to “rod out” the core, and I doubt that aluminum cores will take much of that.

I cannot see a way to do this in an LT-1. I don’t believe that pouring the sealer into the expansion tank of the LT-1 system will circulate it fast enough to be effective, and I guess that there’s a high probability that it would clog up in the plumbing under the tank, in the flow restrictor, or in the various hoses or fittings, before it ever would get to the radiator or heater core. The LT-1 is known for clogging the heater core anyway. I thought about bringing the engine up to temperature, shutting it off, draining some coolant, pulling off one of the radiator hoses, pouring the sealer in the hose, refilling and bleeding the system as quickly as possible. But I never felt that I could do this fast enough, and that there would be a good chance of clogging the air bleeder, anyway, so I gave up on the idea.


Has anyone here ever successfully added sealer to their LT-1? How?
 
I am 5'5" and I can reach in and through that whole part of the dash easily. I scraped myself up a little bit with the door blend actuator but I didn't even have to remove the glovebox. I ordered the new one this morning. I also got a premium thermostat, uses a more variable technology (superstat?) for the valve rather than the standard open/close. Thank you guys for the input. Once you've left blood inside your dash, you're bonded with your car 🙂 all she needs is a name now.
 
I'm one of those that would rather be safe than sorry so I would replace the heater core. It's just the time that becomes an issue.
 
Back
Top