Between the two I’d suggest the Conti PureContact LS. The Michelin Primacy MXM4 is generally an OE tire, which means a car manufacturer had it specced out for a certain vehicle, to hit certain targets (like rolling resistance for CAFE and cost). Drivers are generally happier with replacement tires, which tend to put more emphasis on performance drivers care about (like wet handling, tread life, and snow traction). The PureContact LS is a replacement tire (and a good one). A more comparable Michelin would be the Primacy Tour A/S. The Bridgestone Turanza QuietTrack is another good, premium all season touring tire. The Yokohamas mentioned above are well regarded also.